Pre-tax vs. post-tax health insurance premium payroll deduction

Comparison of Post-Tax and Pre-Tax Deductions for Health Insurance and Flexspending Accounts

INDIVIDUAL COVERAGE (claim single; 0 exemptions)

Post-Tax

Earned Gross $1,000.00
Taxbl Gross* 1,000.00
Fed W/H $94.12
State W/H $33.74
SS $62.00
MDCR $14.50
Net $795.64
Health $56.01
Take Home $739.63

Total difference: $13.39

Pre-Tax

Earned Gross $1,000.00
Health $56.01
Taxbl Gross* $943.99
Fed W/H $88.01
State W/H $30.74
SS $58.53
MDCR $13.69
Net $753.02
Take Home $753.02

FAMILY COVERAGE (claim single; 0 exemptions)

Post-Tax

Earned Gross $1,000.00
Taxbl Gross* 1,000.00
Fed W/H $94.12
State W/H $33.74
SS $62.00
MDCR $14.50
Net $795.64
Health $241.79
Take Home $553.85

Total difference: $57.60

Pre-Tax

Earned Gross $1,000.00
Health $241.79
Taxbl Gross* $758.21
Fed W/H $67.75
State W/H $21.01
SS $47.01
MDCR $10.99
Net $611.45
Take Home $611.45

*This is reported to Social Security Administration on employees' W-2 forms at the end of the year. As a result, individuals' Social Security benefit may be somewhat diminished. Go to www.ssa.gov to calculate your SS benefits.

Back to top